The Dunning Kruger Effect In Trading
How does the Dunning Kruger effect influence traders and how can you combat it?
Most traders start off with a small amount of capital, money that they can afford to lose.
They may have seen a movie, heard a story, or personally know someone that made serious bank in
trading that they decide right then and there that they want a piece of the action too.
After all, the rules are simple, right!?
We buy low, and then we sell high. Simple, elegant, and definitely doable…
More often than not, this initial seed capital is small enough that they don’t feel emotional about it at all.
Make a first trade, execute a simple strategy to perfection, and then BOOM!
They quintuple their money in a matter of hours on some leveraged breakout trade.
Beginners Luck
They’re elated and overcome with excitement.
They now believe in their natural grasp of how trading works and have tangible proof that they can easily make profitable decisions. This is the peak moment where people with limited trading experience overestimate their abilities.
It’s also where the Dunning-Kruger effect takes centre stage. This is a cognitive bias in which people with a lack of knowledge in a subject believe they understand it more than they do. It was famously studied by David Dunning and Justin Kruger using undergraduate students. They showed how incompetent people often overestimate their skills while poor performers sometimes remain unskilled and unaware of their actual shortcomings.
In the trading context, beginners may overestimate their performance, ignore key fundamentals, and dismiss the complexity of market behaviour. They might even start calling car dealerships in anticipation of massive payouts, loading up accounts with money they can’t afford to lose.
The Valley of Despair
Not too far in the future, after a string of bad trades, reality sets in.
They start to realise trading is far more intricate than they initially thought. Suddenly they’re hearing about broader market trends, sentiment analysis, risk management, and a long list of variables affecting price movement.
Confidence plummets — this is the valley of despair on the Dunning Kruger curve, the point where traders become aware of how much they still have to learn. It mirrors what research shows: an average effect where performers underestimating their actual competence occurs as knowledge grows. As traders develop metacognitive ability, they start recognising the limits of their knowledge and skills.
This point can be make-or-break. Some quit entirely, while others push through, learning from their mistakes and refining their approach.
Setting Realistic Expectations
Setting realistic expectations in trading is crucial for a long and sustainable trading career.
Every day, new traders dive in with dreams of quick riches, underestimate their abilities to manage risk, and ignore the steep learning curve. Without proper education, they become another case study in overconfidence and loss.
The traders who last are the ones who treat the market with respect,not as a casino. They understand that short-term wins are not evidence of mastery. They put in the hours, stay humble, and know the market doesn’t owe them anything.
Accepting the possibility of loss
Losses are part of the game. Even the most experienced traders lose money — regularly. The goal isn’t to avoid losses entirely, but to manage and minimise them.
If you want to avoid losses completely? Avoid trading.
On the other end, chasing unrealistic profits because a social media “guru” promised it’s possible is dangerous. Many of these promises require excessive leverage, a high-risk approach that can wipe you out faster than you think.
Creating a solid trading strategy
Creating a solid trading strategy is essential for setting realistic and achievable goals.
Your trading plan should include clear objectives, factoring in your risk tolerance and trading strategy into a well-defined set of rules.
This helps maintain discipline, emotional balance, and self-control.
You can start trading with a demo account as you start developing a new strategy from scratch. Test it out with small amounts of real money as you continue to polish this new strategy, before eventually scaling up.
Nurturing a mindset of patience and continuous learning
The path to consistent profitability is long.
Attend webinars, read books, follow markets, and learn from experienced traders. Remember Jim Rohn’s advice: “Be a student, not a follower.”
Avoid the trap of instant gratification. Recognise the statistical explanation behind early success. Sometimes it’s just variance, not skill. Respect the fact that the market is an evolving organism, and your methods must evolve too.
By accepting that there’s a learning curve — and sometimes even a need to unlearn bad habits — you’ll be better equipped to adapt and improve. Over time, your metacognitive ability will sharpen, helping you make better trading decisions.
Good luck.
Explore more: